Unlike the NBA, the NHL has never been gun shy of making a crazy bunch of deals when the trade deadline hits. This year was no exception to that rule, as every team in the NBA pretty much ignored their flaws, while their winter season counterparts did all kinds of last minute retooling to try and secure the Stanley Cup. This is one of the many reasons why the NHL is more intriguing than the NBA, but that’s fodder for another post.
There were 31 deals made in the 48 hours that led up to the deadline, and don’t worry; I’m not going to break them all down here. If you really want my opinion on Scott Parker going back to the Avalanche, I suppose you can leave a comment. But it’s all about the highlights and lowlights here. So let’s make like Too Short and break it down, yo:
Trades that were really good
*The Islanders getting Richard Zednik from the Capitals. The fact that the Islanders are only one point out of the playoffs is pretty incredible, considering their owner is a complete madman. If they don’t make the post-season, it’s going to surprise zero people. So why not roll the dice on a streaky scorer like Zednik in hopes that he catches fire? Considering he missed a good chunk of the year because of a groin injury, his legs should be a little fresher than others. Even if they gave up a 2nd round pick next year, it’s still worth the gamble. Besides, who wouldn’t love to see an insane dude like Charles Wang give a Stanley Cup victory speech? If this trade doesn’t do it for you, how about…
*…the Islanders also acquiring Ryan Smyth from the Oilers? This is easily the most shocking trade of the day, especially under the circumstances that I heard it happened under. Apparently, the Oilers were trying to re-negotiate the contract of the soon-to-be-free agent Smyth up until about 3:00 pm, when they gave up. Twenty minutes later, Smyth was shipped off to Long Island. Whereas Zednik is a streaky scorer, Smyth is a proven scorer, who is as flashy as he is tough. He’s about as immovable from the crease as the boards are. This trade alone not only puts them in the playoffs, but probably wins them a series.
*The Sharks getting Bill Guerin from the Blues. This move provides veteran leadership on a San Jose team that is loaded with talent, but also saddled with the reputation of not winning when it counts. Guerin changes that. He’s still a great scorer and a nice physical presence in front of the net, which could clear the way for Joe Thornton to actually score a couple of goals in the post-season.
*The Penguins getting Georges Laraque from the Coyotes. Easily the most underrated maneuver of the deadline. Yes, Laraque is an enforcer. However, he gets to be Sidney Crosby’s and Evgeni Malkin’s bodyguard. Opposing teams had better respect the badge. As a result, the two may even have more open ice around them, which is a scary proposition. Plus, he can make enough of a contribution on both ends of the ice to warrant a regular shift, so it’s not like the Pens traded for a one-dimensional guy.
Trades that made me go meh.
*The Red Wings getting Todd Bertuzzi from the Panthers. Bertuzzi has not been the same player since the Steve Moore incident, and part of that reason was because of all the pressure media put on him since the hit. Now he’s been traded to the one U.S. city that scrutinizes their hockey team like they are a Canadian city. This is not a good combination. I know the Wings were looking for a Brendan Shanahan type to clog the net and help out Pavel Datsyuk, but unless Bertuzzi comes out of the gate and flourishes, the Hockeytown faithful will lose their patience with him, and that will get into his head. This will happen at about the middle of March.
*The Senators getting Oleg Saprykin from the Coyotes. Because if there’s one thing that Ottawa has needed based on their past playoff disappointments, is yet another speed guy that has limited playoff character. Any other type of player would have been a better fit for a post-season run than Saprykin. Truly, this is the kind of trade that will doom Ottawa’s playoff run.
*The Sabres getting Ty Conklin from the Blue Jackets, after dealing Martin Biron to the Flyers. I’m guessing this was done for financial purposes, but that doesn’t make the move any smarter. You know why the Oilers made the Stanley Cup Finals last year? Because they actually traded for a guy that prevented Conklin from playing in the playoffs. (And keep in mind he made the biggest screw-up in the playoffs last year when he was forced to step into the action). If Ryan Miller gets banged up, the Sabres now have zero chance of winning the Cup. I’d say the Senators would possibly run Miller in the playoffs because of this fact if they met, but they traded for Saprykin, so they probably won’t make it that far.
Of course, just by merely typing this post, I’ve guaranteed that Smyth will go scoreless in the playoffs and Buffalo will with the Stanley Cup as Ty Conklin wins the Conn Smythe trophy for playoff MVP. But then again, at least I voiced my opinion and took a chance, which is more than can be said for the vast majority of NBA owners.